The ink follows the surface, not the other way round
Most coding failures we are asked to diagnose are described as ink problems and turn out to be surface problems. The code looks acceptable on the line, then flakes, smears or disappears somewhere between the packer and the customer. Nothing was wrong with the cartridge. The ink never bonded, because the surface would not let it.
This page is the reference we use when a material is new to a line: what the surface energy of common packaging actually is, what pretreatment really changes, how fast that treatment fades, and the three tests that settle the question with tools you already have.
The one number that decides adhesion
A liquid wets a solid when the solid's surface energy is higher than the ink's surface tension — and the margin has to be comfortable. Roughly 8–10 mN/m above the ink is the working rule. A couple of units is not enough, even when it reads like a pass on paper.
That single threshold explains most adhesion complaints we are sent. Polyolefins sit below it: HDPE around 28–32 mN/m, PP around 26–28. PET sits above it at 40–42. So the same solvent ink that flakes off an untreated HDPE bottle can hold perfectly on a PET one, which is why plastic is too broad a word to choose an ink by.
| Surface | Surface energy | Family | Pretreatment usually needed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paper, carton, corrugated, raw wood | Absorbent — energy is not the limit | Water-based | None, normally |
| PP | 26–28 mN/m | Solvent fast-dry | Commonly — corona, flame or primer |
| HDPE / LDPE | 28–32 mN/m | Solvent fast-dry | Commonly — corona, flame or primer |
| Metallised film | 32–38 mN/m | Solvent fast-dry | Usually |
| Coated or lacquered metal | 30–38 mN/m | Solvent fast-dry | The lacquer becomes the surface you print on |
| Rigid PVC | 38–40 mN/m | Solvent fast-dry | Often |
| PET | 40–42 mN/m | Solvent fast-dry | Sometimes, depending on grade |
| Polystyrene / ABS | 38–42 mN/m | Solvent fast-dry | Sometimes |
| Aluminium, uncoated | High, but oxide layer is unstable | Solvent fast-dry | Cleanliness matters more than energy |
| Glass | High, but chemically inert | Solvent fast-dry | Adhesion rides on the primer |
| Silicone-coated release liner | Very low | Not viable — no ink holds | Do not print on it |
| Any of the above, covert marking | Follows the carrier surface | Covert UV | Follows the carrier surface |
Ranges are published industry values and general engineering rules, not measurements of your material. Surface energy moves with grade, additive package and surface state.
Three ways buyers get the surface wrong
Clear is not the same as one material. A clear bottle can be PET, PP or PVC, and the three behave completely differently under the same ink. Buying by appearance, or by the word a supplier used, is the commonest route to a failed first trial. Ask for the resin code, not the look.
Recycled content changes the surface. Post-consumer resin carries additives, residual contamination and a different additive package from virgin stock. A formulation validated on virgin HDPE is not automatically validated on a recycled grade, even when the density and melt flow match.
Additives migrate. Slip agents, antiblock and mold-release compounds are formulated to come to the surface — that is their job. When they do, the surface you print on is no longer the polymer. A batch that printed well last quarter can refuse ink this quarter without any change to the resin code.
The same logic explains why two plants using identical material can get opposite results. Treatment level, storage time, ambient humidity and the additive package all move the effective surface energy, and only one of those is printed on the bag the material arrives in.
What treatment changes, and how fast it fades
Four methods cover almost everything in packaging. They differ in how deep the change goes, how uniform it is, and how long it lasts.
Corona discharge
Raises surface energy by oxidising the top few molecular layers.
Watch for: Decays in storage. Ask for the current dyne level, not the figure on the certificate that shipped with the roll.
Flame treatment
Same effect as corona with more depth, and it tolerates thicker sections and irregular shapes.
Watch for: Heat input must be controlled. Over-treatment embrittles the surface and can create a weak boundary layer.
Chemical primer
A thin coating that becomes the surface you actually print on.
Watch for: Adds a process step and a drying step. It also moves the failure mode from the polymer to the primer.
Plasma
The most uniform option for 3D parts and small components.
Watch for: Batch equipment, so it suits formed parts rather than high-speed web.
Treatment is not permanent. Corona and flame effects decay over time as the oxidised layer reorients and low-molecular-weight material migrates back to the surface. Stock that has sat in a warehouse for months is not the same material that left the converter. When a trial fails on stored material but passes on a fresh sample, treatment decay is the first thing to check — and the fix is a dyne reading at print time, not a different cartridge.
Over-treatment is a real failure mode too. Push corona energy far enough and you build a weak boundary layer that lets the ink film lift cleanly, which reads as poor adhesion even though the surface energy number looks excellent. More treatment is not automatically better.
When the coating becomes the surface
Lacquers, varnishes, primers and label face stocks all change the question. Once a coating is present, the polymer underneath is no longer what the ink touches, and the energy value you looked up for the resin no longer applies.
Three consequences are worth carrying into a trial. A lacquer usually raises energy and improves adhesion, but it also introduces a second interface that can fail — and it will fail on the coating side, not the polymer side. A release liner or a label with a slip additive presents a deliberately low-energy face, so printing on the back of a label stock is not a formulation problem, it is a wrong-surface problem. And a matte or soft-touch coating often carries a low-energy top layer that reads as premium in the hand and repels ink completely.
Ask what the topcoat is before you ask what the ink should be. That order saves trials.
Three tests with a dyne pen, tape and water
None of these need a laboratory. Run them in this order: the water bead screens, the dyne pen measures, the tape pull confirms that the measurement translates into a bond that survives handling.
1. Dyne pen
Draw a short stroke across the surface with the lowest-numbered pen in the set, wait three seconds, and read it. If the ink holds a continuous film, that value is at or below the surface energy. If it beads into droplets within two seconds, move to the next pen down.
How to read it: You are looking for a surface energy at least 8–10 mN/m above your ink surface tension. A reading that barely passes is a failure waiting for a warm day.
2. Tape pull
Print, let the code cure for the full interval your process allows, apply standard adhesive tape over it, press firmly, and pull back at a shallow angle in one motion.
How to read it: Clean removal with no ink on the tape means adhesion is adequate. Ink transferring to the tape means the bond is weaker than the tape adhesive, which is a low bar to fail.
3. Water bead
Place a single drop of water on the surface and watch the contact angle for ten seconds.
How to read it: A drop that stays rounded and rolls off points to low energy; a drop that flattens and spreads points to a wettable surface. It is a screening test, not a measurement — use it to spot which samples deserve a dyne pen.
One discipline makes these results usable: test the material as it arrives at the print head, not as it arrives in the loading bay. A sample that has been sitting on a desk for a week is a different surface from one pulled straight off the line.
Drying is a line-layout question
Drying is not a datasheet number. What matters is where the first contact happens: the first roller, the first stacker, the first time two printed faces touch. Give us that distance and the line speed, and the drying budget becomes arithmetic.
Changing the cartridge almost never fixes a drying problem created by line layout. If the code has 300 mm and 0.4 seconds to dry before it meets a belt, a faster ink buys margin for a while, then the line runs faster and the margin disappears again. Move the print head, add a short air knife, or accept a slower ramp — those fix the cause.
Substrate to cartridge, in one table
This is the short version of everything above. Treat it as the starting point for a trial, not as a specification — your material has the final word.
| Substrate | Ink | Pretreatment | Where it usually goes wrong |
|---|---|---|---|
| Corrugated, carton, paper, wood | Water-based | None | Lowest cost, dries fast, no odour control needed |
| HDPE, LDPE, PP — bottles, caps, film | Solvent fast-dry | Corona or flame, verified at print time | The largest single group of adhesion complaints |
| PET — bottles, film, metallised | Solvent fast-dry | Depends on grade and whether the face is treated | Do not assume PET behaves like the PET you used last year |
| Rigid PVC, PS, ABS | Solvent fast-dry | Often, verify per batch | Additive packages vary widely between suppliers |
| Coated metal, lacquered cans | Solvent fast-dry | The coating is the surface | Cleanliness of the coating decides more than the metal |
| Glass | Solvent fast-dry | Primer, usually | Adhesion failures here are almost always primer or cleanliness |
| Any surface, mark must be invisible | Covert UV | Follows the carrier surface | Read under 365 nm; not a readability solution |
For the two cartridges this table points at, see the TIJ 2.5 solvent cartridge and the covert UV cartridge. If the surface is settled and the code still fails, the problem is usually shape rather than chemistry — folds, condensation, heat seals and abrasion are covered in choosing ink by container type.
What to send before you ask for a quote
A substrate enquiry that says plastic bottle cannot be answered well. Five details turn it into a trial that has a chance of working first time.
- 1 The resin code and the colour, so we can separate PET from PP from PVC.
- 2 Whether the face you print on is treated, and the dyne level if your converter can supply it.
- 3 Whether there is a lacquer, varnish or topcoat — and what it is.
- 4 The code content: one text line, or a 2D symbol sharing the band with one.
- 5 A photo of a current failure, plus the conditions it fails under.
Related reading
- Water-based versus solvent-based TIJ ink — the porous, semi-porous and non-porous split, with dry time and cost trade-offs.
- Ink that will not stick to plastic film — what low surface energy does at the droplet level, and how long corona lasts.
- Solvent ink on metal — the flat, high-energy case where cleanliness beats formulation.
- Choosing ink by container type — pouches, bottles, tubes, blisters and sleeves, and where each one fails.
- Codes fading on cold PET bottles — when a water film, not the resin, is the surface you are printing on.
Get Started
READY TO SCALE
YOUR PRINT OPERATION?
Send us your printer model and monthly volume. We'll respond within 24 hours with pricing, spec sheets, and sample availability.